0
Marold Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

Needn't have vs. didn't need vs. didn't have to

He didn't have to buy the bread.

He needn't have bought the bread.

He didn't need to buy the bread.

Which of these sentences imply that he bought the bread or not?
  

Top answer

Only the second clearly says that he bought it.

  • Only the second clearly says that he bought it.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
Only the second clearly says that he bought it.
0
He doesn't have to buy any bread.

He needn't buy any bread.

He doesn't need to buy any bread.

What about these ones in the present? What are the implications? In which sentences does he plan to buy the bread?
Are these sentences entirely the same?

He needn't buy any bread.

He doesn't need to buy any bread.
0
He doesn't have to buy any bread.
He needn't buy any bread.
He doesn't need to buy any bread.

What about these ones in the present? What are the implications? -- None.
In which sentences does he plan to buy the bread?-- They say nothing about his intentions
Are these sentences entirely the same?- Yes.
He needn't buy any bread.
He doesn't need

Related Questions