0
Walk grape 365 Posted 6 years ago
Grammar

Multiple restrictive clauses

John ran from a dog he knew was rabid trying to bite him. Is "he knew was rabid trying to bite him" one restrictive clause? Is it two: "he knew was rabid" and "trying to bite him"? If it's two, can "trying to bite him" modify "dog" or "he knew was rabid," or does it necessarily modify the immediately preceding clause, "he knew was rabid"?
  

Top answer

John ran from a dog [ he knew was rabid [ trying to bite him ]] It's a special form of 'stacking', which occurs where a defining (restrictive) relative clause combines with its antecedent to form a larger unit which is modified by a non-finite clause that is sometimes called a reduced relative clause. In your example, he knew was rabid combines with its antecedent dog to give the noun phrase dog he knew was rabid and this is then modified by the clause trying to bite him .

  • John ran from a dog [ he knew was rabid [ trying to bite him ]] It's a special form of 'stacking', which occurs where a defining (restrictive) relative clause combines with its antecedent to form a larger unit which is modified by a non-finite clause that is sometimes called a reduced relative clause.
  • In your example, he knew was rabid combines with its antecedent dog to give the noun phrase dog he knew was rabid and this is then modified by the clause trying to bite him .
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

John ran from a dog [he knew was rabid [trying to bite him]]

It's a special form of 'stacking', which occurs where a defining (restrictive) relative clause combines with its antecedent to form a larger unit which is modified by a non-finite clause that is sometimes called a reduced relative clause.

In your example, he knew was rabid combine

Related Questions