0
Bảo Lê Quốc Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

Mixed condition

if the comic book --- by now, I would have lent you.
A. arrived
B. had arrived

Because "now" appears in if-clause, so I choose A to suit mixed conditional sentence,
or because the action "I would have lent you" must happen after "the comic book had arrived" so we use past perfect in if-clause?

  

Top answer

o Lê Quô´c Because "now" appears in if-clause, It is not 'now'; it is 'by now'—a time before now. o Lê Quô´c because the action "I would have lent you" must happen after "the comic book had arrived" so we use past perfect in if-clause? That is the wrong argument.

  • o Lê Quô´c Because "now" appears in if-clause, It is not 'now'; it is 'by now'—a time before now.
  • o Lê Quô´c because the action "I would have lent you" must happen after "the comic book had arrived" so we use past perfect in if-clause?
  • That is the wrong argument.
  • If one event must happen after another event, then simple past is used, not past perfect.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
Ba?o Lê Quô´cBecause "now" appears in if-clause,

It is not 'now'; it is 'by now'—a time before now.

Ba?o Lê Quô´cbecause the action "I would have lent you" must happen after "the comic book had arrived" so we use past perfect in if-clause?

That is the wrong argument. If one event must happen after another event, t

Related Questions