0
Pructus Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

Made him do it

Hello...

Do both A and B mean that he actually did it, if no more context is provided?

A. They made him do it.
B. He was made to do it.
  

Top answer

Only A does. That said, the two don't mean the same thing. The made in the first means "forced", whereas the second made is similar to "born".

  • Only A does.
  • That said, the two don't mean the same thing.
  • The made in the first means "forced", whereas the second made is similar to "born".
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

6 Answers
0
Only A does.

That said, the two don't mean the same thing. The made in the first means "forced", whereas the second made is similar to "born".
0
I see, Ivanhr....

Thanks a lot...

By the way...

"He was made to do it" cannot be understood to mean "He was forced to do it"?
0
pructus"He was made to do it" cannot be understood to mean "He was forced to do it"?
I wouldn't rule it out if the context suggested it, but B is ambiguous. A is not.
0
I see....

Thanks Blue Jay!!
0
pructusDo both A and B mean that he actually did it, if no more context is provided?A. They made him do it.B. He was made to do it.
Yipes! I am surprised at the answers. B is merely the passive form of A. They both indicate that he did it against his will. I don't see how a person can be 'made' (= born) to do something. They can be born to do, or they can
0
Oh, thanks so much, Mister Micawber!!

Related Questions