0
Magda Posted 20 years ago
Grammar

Like and as

Hi,
I am doing "like" and "as" used in comparisions, e.g
"Kate dresses like her mother" and
"Kate dresses as her mother does."

Could you tell me whether these two ( I mean "as" and "like") can ever be used in a sentence interchangeably?

Thank you.
  

Top answer

I'd say that, in the examples you've given, they are interchangeable. Yet, if you omit the "does", the meaning changes: "she dresses like her mother" => she wears the same kind of clothes as her mother. // "She dresses as her mother" => she dresses so as to impersonate her mother.

  • I'd say that, in the examples you've given, they are interchangeable.
  • Yet, if you omit the "does", the meaning changes: "she dresses like her mother" => she wears the same kind of clothes as her mother.
  • // "She dresses as her mother" => she dresses so as to impersonate her mother.
  • //"She works as a slave" => that's her job: slave.
  • I'm not quite sure I've answered your question...
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

15 Answers
0
I'd say that, in the examples you've given, they are interchangeable.

Yet, if you omit the "does", the meaning changes: "she dresses like her mother" => she wears the same kind of clothes as her mother. // "She dresses as her mother" => she dresses so as to impersonate her mother.

Likewise: "she works like a slave" (that's my favourite example!) => she works as much as a
0
both seem ok to me, although in the UK we'd be more likely to say "dresses like...", or "dresses the same as...", rather than "dresses as..."
0
Hi pieanne,
thanks for your answers Emotion: smile. Yes, I wondered if you can say "she dresseslike/as her mother", and thanks
0
I've got another question. Can I say: "Sometimes you sound just like/as my mum!"?
Can I replace "like" with "as"?
0
I'd always use "like".

But then, I'm not a native, as you can see! Emotion: smile
0
Pieanne may not be a native, but she's right!
0
Thank you both Emotion: smile .

Have a nice evening!
0
I'd always use 'like' too. "sometimes you sound like...". Never use 'as' in this context unless it's a simile, ie: "sometimes you sound as common as muck", or something like that.
0
In the late 1950's a cigarette commercial was highly criticized by academes: "Winston tastes good like a cig- cig- cigarette should". The contention was that since "like" was followed by a clause with a verb it should have been "as". Walk like me vs. walk as I do. I'm not sure it's considered very important these days, but then we don't have Bennett Cerf and Dorothy Kilg

Related Questions