0
Russian80 Posted 7 years ago
Grammar

- John is no longer interested in football, is he? - Doesn't seem to be yet. (illogical?)

The context: John is a semi-professional football player but for some reason stopped coming to the training last week.

How would the following dialogues between the trainer and John's wife be perceived by a native English speaker, and what is the difference in meaning between his wife's answers:


- John is no longer interested in football, is he?

- Doesn't seem to be yet.

/ this answer, given by an Indian woman, seems illogical since John has long been playing football


- John is no longer interested in football, is he?

- He doesn't seem to be yet.

/ this answer seems illogical since John has long been playing football


- John is no longer interested in football, is he?

- He doesn't seem to so be yet.

(so = no longer interested ?

so = interested ? )

The question: can "so" stand for negative predicates?

- John is no longer interested in football, is he?

- It doesn't seem to be yet.

- John is no longer interested in football, is he?

- It doesn't seem to be so yet.

- John is no longer interested in football, is he?

- It doesn't seem to be the case yet.

/ this answer is pretty unambiguous

  

Top answer

3534331 /

  • 3534331 /
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

Already answered https://www.usingenglish.com/forum/threads/267667-quot-Have-an-interest-in-quot-vs-quot-Get-interested-in-quot-non-recurrent-(state)-vs-recccure and

Related Questions