0
ShatteredEquilibrium Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

it is in... + where or that?

Since "in" points to a place, I've been wondering whether I shouldn't put where instead of that in the following sentence:

IT IS IN this callous destruction and reckless exploitation of the natural environment WHERE / THAT resides the most telling testimony to the degeneration of the humanity of man and his now almost non-existent empathy towards the planet that gives him life.

Could anyone help dispel my doubts please? Emotion: wink
  

Top answer

No, "in" does not always point to a place. "in" is commonly used for many other things: situations, circumstances, consultations, predicaments, etc. Don't use 'where' there.

  • No, "in" does not always point to a place.
  • "in" is commonly used for many other things: situations, circumstances, consultations, predicaments, etc.
  • Don't use 'where' there.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
No, "in" does not always point to a place. "in" is commonly used for many other things: situations, circumstances, consultations, predicaments, etc. Don't use 'where' there.
0
That sounds better to this native speaker.

Related Questions