0
Mezzopiano Posted 7 years ago
Essay & Composition Writing

It is a sad but just indictment of some high school history textbook

Hi Can someone explain what this sentence means please? I can't figure out the grammar components for this sentence. Thank you

It is a sad but just indictment of some high school history textbooks that they frequently report as controversial claims that historians hotly debate or that are even completely contradicted by reliable primary sources.

  

Top answer

Below is a simplified paraphrase of your text. Here is a sad but fair criticism of some history text-books that are used in high school. They frequently say that matters which historians argue about are controversial.

  • Below is a simplified paraphrase of your text.
  • Here is a sad but fair criticism of some history text-books that are used in high school.
  • They frequently say that matters which historians argue about are controversial.
  • (The word controversial seems fair to me here, because historians are arguing.
  • ) These text books also say that some matters are controversial when all the evidence shows that they are completely true If there are parts that are still unclear to you, please tell us which parts they are.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

Below is a simplified paraphrase of your text.

Here is a sad but fair criticism of some history text-books that are used in high school.

They frequently say that matters which historians argue about are controversial. (The word controversial seems fair to me here, because historians are arguing. I don't know why the writer of this text thinks it is not.)

These

Related Questions