0
Akdom Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

It hadn't been a lie.

"Forgive me, but I've--I've got an appointment." A smile curved across her mouth. It hadn't been a lie, not in the strick sense of the word.

Could you explain why use "hadn't been a lie" here? Why the Past Perfect?

it hadn't been a lie (PastPerfect)

it wasn't a lie (Simple Past)

I would rather use It wasn't a lie.

I am very confused. Please explain to me that the different sense it conveys when Past Perfect is used and when Simple Past is used.
  

Top answer

And I would rather use 'strict'. The option is open here; evidently the writer wishes to make clear the sequence of events: the thought came first, and then came the smile.

  • And I would rather use 'strict'.
  • The option is open here; evidently the writer wishes to make clear the sequence of events: the thought came first, and then came the smile.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
And I would rather use 'strict'.

The option is open here; evidently the writer wishes to make clear the sequence of events: the thought came first, and then came the smile.

Related Questions