0
Hanuman_2000 Posted 19 years ago
Grammar

is/was

Hello,

1. She ________ (is /was/will be) my sister.

Which one is correct choice?
  

Top answer

If she is your sister, she is always your sister, so there's no good reason to use past or future. She is my sister. CJ

  • If she is your sister, she is always your sister, so there's no good reason to use past or future.
  • She is my sister.
  • CJ
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
If she is your sister, she is always your sister, so there's no good reason to use past or future.

She is my sister.

CJ
0
Hi,

Unless perhaps she is dead or has not been born yet.Emotion: smile

Clive
0
Quite right, but that information was not given as part of the problem to be solved! Emotion: wink

CJ
0
hanuman,

Is your sister dead?
Is your sister not yet born?

CJ
0
CalifJimIf she is your sister, she is always your sister, so there's no good reason to use past or future.

She is my sister.

Hmmm...
Hi,
no reason to use the past? I remember I once learned (from you) that the past doesn't necessarily say something about the present situation.
- Hey did you see that girl just now? Wh
0
- Hey did you see that girl just now? Who was that?
- Oh, that was my sister...

...
- Hey did you see that girl just now? Who was she?
- Oh, she was my sister...
Both of your examples show correct usage.

(Note that you have provided very specific contexts not given in the original post.
0
Hello Mr.C.J,

This was the problem given to a boy to solve it and he asked me.

I was a little bit confused and tried to clear it.

No context is given.
0
Hello, hanuman,

Yes, I understand. I think a lot of us here on the forum are a little bit confused also. Emotion: smile
I think

Related Questions