0
Anonymous Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

Is "with" correct?

Hi!

Is "with" correct in this context?

If pain in the left knee persists, it is recommended to attend a repeated consultation with a traumatologist-orthopaedist.

Thank you!
  

Top answer

'with' is fine. Overall, your sentence sounds very stilted (as does a lot of medical English). A more straightforward version is this.

  • 'with' is fine.
  • Overall, your sentence sounds very stilted (as does a lot of medical English).
  • A more straightforward version is this.
  • eg If pain in left knee persists, I recommend a consultation with a traumatologist-orthopaedist.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
'with' is fine.

Overall, your sentence sounds very stilted (as does a lot of medical English).
A more straightforward version is this.

eg If pain in left knee persists, I recommend a consultation wi
0
“…it is recommended to the patient make an appointment for further consultation with a …”
It is unusual to ‘attend with’ unless both parties are travelling to a common location.
0
AnonymousIs "with" correct in this context?
Yes, you "consult with (someone)". However, in my neighborhood we would say it something like one of these:

If pain in the left knee persists, physical therapy sessions are recommended.
If the pain in the left knee persists, we recommend enrolling in a program of physical therapy.

CJ

Related Questions