0
Jasonlee Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

Is this sentence wrong?

She wanted him to please put up a better sign for kids like her.

Someone says the word 'please' is wrong.
But someone says the word please is right, because it is used as an adverb.

Give me some advice, please.
  

Top answer

Please as an adverb is a polite word added to command or request. Thus, you have said the word 'please'. "

  • Please as an adverb is a polite word added to command or request.
  • Thus, you have said the word 'please'.
  • "
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

6 Answers
0
Please as an adverb is a polite word added to command or request.

Thus, you have said the word 'please'.

Then, your sentence should read as

She said to him, "Please put up a better sign for kids like her."
0
Thanks, vsuresh.
So the sentence, "She wanted him to please put up a better sign for kids like her." is right, isn't it?
0
jasonleeSo the sentence, "She wanted him to please put up a better sign for kids like her." is right, isn't it?
Yes.

And, if you want to convey the meaning of please in indirect speech, your sentence can read like this.

She made a polite (in place of please) request to him to put up a better sign for kids like her.
0
So, which one is better?
1) She wanted him to "Please put up a better sign for kids like her."
2) She wanted him to please put up a better sign for kids like her.

Both are OK?
0
We normally use the verb "ask" when reporting a request indirectly:

She asked him to put up a better sign for kids like her.
0
To ozzourti

Man: What does she want to do at the gate?
Woman: She wanted him to please put up a better sign for kids like her

The woman's saying is acceptable, but is not usual expression. Am I right?

Related Questions