0
Anonymous Posted 5 years ago
Grammar

Is this OK and punctuated as you would have?

1: Diane turns back to her husband to yell at him again, when she notices that their daughter is gone.

2: Diane turns back to her husband, about to yell at him again, when she notices that their daughter is gone.

3: Diane turns back to her husband and is about to yell at him again, when she notices that their daughter is gone.


- Are the three versions equally good? Are they punctuated as you would have?

- Is "is gone" correct?

  

Top answer

anonymous - Are the three versions equally good? Yes, as far as the English goes. The third one is a bit wordy.

  • anonymous - Are the three versions equally good?
  • Yes, as far as the English goes.
  • The third one is a bit wordy.
  • anonymous Are they punctuated as you would have?
  • I would have to be talked into leaving the commas in 1 and 3 because they make "when" look like a coordinating conjunction, but in fiction you can put a comma there if you think it helps.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
anonymous- Are the three versions equally good?

Yes, as far as the English goes. The third one is a bit wordy.

anonymousAre they punctuated as you would have?

I would have to be talked into leaving the commas in 1 and 3 because they make "when" look like a coordinating conjunction, but in fiction you can put a comm

Related Questions