But i didn't get you why it doesn't make sense?Lets suppose i am going to wish my friend happy birthday.Then she replies me thanks.Then i reply, My pleasure.You should also give us a chance to say thanks to you by giving us a birthday treat.In this case is it making sense or not sir?
You should also give us a chance to say thanks to you by giving us a birthday treat -- This does not make sense. We do not ask others to give us a gift.