0
Viceidol Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Is that your student? Yes it/he is. ←which is correct?

Q1: Is that your student?

A1: Yes, he is.

Yes, it is.

Q2: That is your student, isn't it?

A2: Yes, he is.

Yes, it is.

Q3: That's your sister, look!

A3: So she is!

So it is!

May I ask what kind of pronoun should I use in those answers? Which is correct (or most commonly used)? Is it "wrong" to use "it"?

Thank you for your help!
  

Top answer

Use the version with it in all three. CJ

— CalifJim

  • Use the version with it in all three.
  • CJ
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
Use the version with it in all three.

CJ
0
0
Hi,

Q1: Is that your student?

A1: Yes, he is.

Yes, it is.

Q2: That is your student, isn't it?

A2: Yes, he is.

Yes,

0
0
I understand now, thank you, CalifJim and Clive.
0
0
Hi,
can I ask about these too?

- Is that girl over there your sister?
- Yes, she is.

- Is that your mom?
- Yes, it's my mom.

Thanks.
0
0
KooyeenHi,
can I ask about these too?

- Is that girl over there your sister?
- Yes, she is. With the words 'that girl' in the sentence, you might hear people use either 'she' or 'it' in the tag.

- Is that your mom?
- Yes, it's my mom.
0
0
Heh, it wasn't so simple then... it's pretty complicated in reality. I'll have to be careful, although being careful is a pain in the neck.
0
0
Well, there are also plenty of times people will simply say "Yeah" or "Yup" -- or maybe even a proper "Yes" (gasp!) -- and not add a tag at all.
0

Related Questions