0
Anonymous Posted 5 years ago
Grammar

Ing/Ed Clauses and Relative Clauses

Hello there,


Can I ask you some questions regarding ing/ed and relative clause?


There are two types of relative clauses -- defining and non-defining. When we use a non-defining relative clause, we must use a comma. Moreover, we can use ing/ed clauses instead of relative pronouns. I wonder whether when we use ing/ed clauses, the rule which is using non-defining clauses regarding comma is apply to ing/ed clauses.


For example, I visited a statue which is located in the center of Paris = I visited a statue located in the center of Paris.

I visited the statue of liberty, which is made of copper. In this situation, which sentence is correct, I visited the statue of liberty made of copper, or I visited the statue of liberty, made of copper.


Or, Are there any rules regarding ing/ed clause on whether ing/ed clauses do not use as a non-defining clause like relative pronoun that.


Thank you!

  

Top answer

anonymous In this situation, which sentence is correct, I visited the statue of liberty made of copper, or I visited the statue of liberty, made of copper. Neither is correct. Even so, it is not very natural.

  • anonymous In this situation, which sentence is correct, I visited the statue of liberty made of copper, or I visited the statue of liberty, made of copper.
  • Neither is correct.
  • Even so, it is not very natural.
  • I visited the S tatue of L iberty, which is made of copper.
  • I visited the S tatue of L iberty, located on Ellis Island.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
anonymousIn this situation, which sentence is correct, I visited the statue of liberty made of copper, or I visited the statue of liberty, made of copper.

Neither is correct. Even so, it is not very natural.

I visited the Statue of Liberty,

Related Questions