0
Bobzhao Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Incompetent or incapable

However they appear, as pure spirit or in human form, they are wise, powerful and incompetent of death.

Here is a quiz of a sentence correction from our grammar book. The correction is to replace "imcompetent" with "incapable". I agree but I think "in" also should be deleted from "in human form" because as pure spirit or human form are both noun phrase. Am I right?
  

Top answer

Hello, Bob—and welcome to English Forums. 'Inompetent of death' makes no sense. 'Incapable of death' is marginally sensible (that is, I understand what the writer is trying to say).

  • Hello, Bob—and welcome to English Forums.
  • 'Inompetent of death' makes no sense.
  • 'Incapable of death' is marginally sensible (that is, I understand what the writer is trying to say).
  • What s/he means is 'wise, powerful and immortal '.
  • 'In' is necessary.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
Hello, Bob—and welcome to English Forums.

'Inompetent of death' makes no sense. 'Incapable of death' is marginally sensible (that is, I understand what the writer is trying to say). What s/he means is 'wise, powerful and immortal'.

'In' is necessary. You would not need 'in' if 'form' were omitted: 'as pure spirit or human' would be OK.

Related Questions