0
Nerdikarp Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

In this sentence, which has the color yellow? "The bell that crushed the house, which has the color yellow..."

"The bell that crushed the house, which has the color yellow..."

Which is yellow, the bell or the house?

Thanks!
  

Top answer

Impossible to tell -- it's ambiguous. It's also rather strange, in several ways. Why "has the color yellow" instead of just "is yellow"?

  • Impossible to tell -- it's ambiguous.
  • It's also rather strange, in several ways.
  • Why "has the color yellow" instead of just "is yellow"?
  • How can a bell crush a house?
  • What's the rest of the sentence?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

5 Answers
0
Impossible to tell -- it's ambiguous. It's also rather strange, in several ways. Why "has the color yellow" instead of just "is yellow"? How can a bell crush a house? What's the rest of the sentence?

I suppose if I really had to guess, I would say that the bell is yellow. Since the house has been crushed, it might be more appropriate to say that the house had the color yellow
0
nerdikarp"The bell that crushed the house, which has the color yellow..."Which is yellow, the bell or the house?
You think that's ambiguous? Well, you haven't seen anything yet.
0
Ouch! That one makes my head hurt. Emotion: tongue tied

p.s. Botulism kills more mallard ducks than weasels!
0
This sentence in particular is quite vague, but if you properly assess it you can see that it is the house which is the color yellow. A better way of phrasing that would be "The bell that crushed the yellow house..."
0
The example given was not even a complete sentence -- how exactly did you "properly assess" it to determine your answer? Why suggest "the bell that crushed the yellow house" instead of "The yellow bell that crushed the house"?

As I said earlier, I think it's clearly ambiguous; but if I had to guess I would say that it's the bell that's yellow, as the crushed house would probably be descr

Related Questions