0
Anonymous Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Imperative that (we are/we be)?

Which is grammatically correct?
"It is imperative that we are willing to...." or "It is imperative that we be willing to..."
  

Top answer

Both are correct. The subjunctive be is rather formal. CB

  • Both are correct.
  • The subjunctive be is rather formal.
  • CB
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
Both are correct. The subjunctive be is rather formal.

CB
0
"It is imperative that we are... " sounds very strange to me. If we "are" (whatever), it's already a fact -- it's like saying "It's imperative that the earth is round." (It reminds me of a converasion in one of the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy books that included such lines as "I demand that I am a philosopher!)
0
Thanks to both of you guys. I agree with you, khoff, I thought that "we are" sounded strange too. It seemed to me that a claim about something that should be true, but actually isn't true (which is what the full sentence was doing), shouldn't be stated like that. I didn't really give the context, but I'm pretty sure "we be" makes more sense.
0
AnonymousWhich is grammatically correct?
Grammatically, this one: "It is imperative that we be willing to..."

But in practical, logical terms, it seems a bit anomalous to me to make commands concerning internal states (such as willingness). Compare this with the even more anomalous:

It is imperative that you enjoy this movie.

Related Questions