0
Mango pen 189 Posted 7 years ago
Grammar

Imagine someone to be/ ımagine someone being/ imagine someone is

This websites says: "imagine can be followed by either (a) a gerund or (b) a noun phrase or pronoun + to-infinitive but with different meanings". And gives examples:

a- Imagine living at 2,000 metres above sea level! (Imagine what it would be like to live at 2,000 metres above sea level.)

b- I imagined him to be much taller. (I expected that he would be much taller.)


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Is this difference in meaning always implied? Don't these examples below convey almost the same thing:

1- Imagine that you are lying on a beach. (https://www.macmillandictionary.com/dictionary/british/imagine)

2- Imagine yourself lying on a beach.

3- Imagine yourself to be lying on a beach.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

4- I think they imagine the company to be bigger than it is. (https://www.macmillandictionary.com/dictionary/british/imagine)

5- I think they imagine the company is bigger than it is.

6- I think they imagine the company being bigger than it is. (Probably this sentence is not the appropriate one.)
  

Top answer

Some examples: a. Imagine living at 2000m above sea level. = Imagine what it would be like to live at 2000m above sea level.

  • Some examples: a.
  • Imagine living at 2000m above sea level.
  • = Imagine what it would be like to live at 2000m above sea level.
  • ) Imagine you are living 2000m above sea level = Imagine that you are actually living in a house 2000m above sea level.
  • Imagine yourself to be living 2000m above sea level.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0

Some examples:


a. Imagine living at 2000m above sea level. = Imagine what it would be like to live at 2000m above sea level. (Note: this is the only example that has a different meaning from the two following examples.)

Imagine you are living 2000m above sea level = Imagine that you are actually living in a house 2000m above sea level.

Imagine yourself to be liv

0
mango pen 189Don't these examples below convey almost the same thing

That doesn't matter. The web page is specifically about

Verbs followed by the TO-infinitive or gerund with a difference in meaning,

just as it says at the top of the page.

So obviously they are not going to discuss sentences like

Related Questions