0
Usenet Posted 21 years ago
Screenwriting

I'm thankful for this newsgroup.

So I'm sittin' here, not writing, weeding out my outbox (in a nice way, I mean) and I came across a past post that makes me thankful for the on- and off-topic threads I've enjoyed over the years with you people.

Happy Thanksgiving, everyone.
Joe Myers
"Even Skip, who should be thankful
he's not crazier than he is."

(snips)
[nq:1]...this story would be after the war - The Constitutional Convention. It wouldn't be sugar-coated either. Warts and all. Has ... sex and substance abuse and drunken fighting in the streets. James Madison could be the main protagonist and stay sober...[/nq]
I think your problem would be with the "warts."
Given the conservative revisionist "original intent" crowd and their counterpart "politically correct" nigglers on the other side of the political
spectrum, people would hate the truth and just about any interpretation that would fill in gaps of the historical record.
For starters, your cast is a bunch of white guys.
Washington was a hemp farmer. Franklin was a womanizer. Just about everybody in those days drank a lot more rum than is considered socially acceptable these days. So you're right, a lot of sex and drugs and 18th Century rock 'n' roll (sitting around and singing the original lyrics to "Anacreon in Heaven," perhaps?) would be in the mix between sessions of the Continental Congress. There'd probably be a prostitute in the story and you'd lose Lois from the get-go.
And then there's the old 3/5th of a person issue. Like it or not, this nation's foundation was set in ink on parchment as thoroughly and decidedly racist. It's taken over 200 years, a bloody civil war, associations, filibusters, affirmative action and backlash to attempt to extricate ourselves from that, ahem, tar baby. And an authentic dramatization of how that issue was handled in 1789 would distress 21st Century ears.

Ultimately, the story is one about compromise. Big States, Little States, North, South, free, slave. If you got into the Bill of Rights, someone would have to depict how the Second Amendment got such strange punctuation, to the degree no one really knows how the Founding Fathers might vote on AK-47s in the classroom. The NRA and Handgun Control would be picketing every theater in the country.
An accurate portrayal of the theists who hammered out the document would *** off 21st Century Evangelicalists. More pickets outside theaters.

You'd have more people outside theaters than in.
Joe Myers
"Forget it, Jake. It's Philadelphia."
  

Top answer

I'm thankful too. (That I didn't try to write this film). Thanks for stopping me.

  • I'm thankful too.
  • (That I didn't try to write this film).
  • Thanks for stopping me.
  • I love each and every one of y'all and all your pets.
  • Remember to hug your pets for Thanksgiving.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

12 Answers
0
I'm thankful too. (That I didn't try to write this film). Thanks for stopping me.
I love each and every one of y'all and all your pets. Remember to hug your pets for Thanksgiving. And thanks to all of y'all for letting me waste my life with all of y'all. It would not have been the same as wasting it alone.
)
0
[nq:1]Happy Thanksgiving, everyone.[/nq]
The same to you and everyone else.

Dena Jo
Email goes to denajo2 at the dot com variation of the Yahoo domain.

Plonk the ********: http://www.panix.com/~mwsm/trolls.html
0
[nq:1]I'm thankful too. (That I didn't try to write this film). Thanks for stopping me. I love each and every ... me waste my life with all of y'all. It would not have been the same as wasting it alone.
0
Our country was founded by renegades who also wore pilgrim hats. We sometimes pretend to be puritanical but also have moonshine, jazz, and turduckens. We are an enigma.
I propose NOT that anyone go against their beliefs to be good and pure and kind and always do no harm, BUT can we really ever be thankful if we don't explore the bountifulness that is America and enjoy it?! Our music, our art,
0
[nq:1]Our country was founded by renegades who also wore pilgrim hats. We sometimes pretend to be puritanical but also have ... friends. Enjoy, eat, drink, dance, be merry and make someone somewhere feel better about themselves. Cheers to my fellow writers![/nq]
Thank you, Suzy. May happiness fill your heart this Thanksgiving! (Eh... And everybody else's too.)
Being in ****d*, I've already
0
[nq:1]Our country was founded by renegades who also wore pilgrim hats. We sometimes pretend to be puritanical but also have ... friends. Enjoy, eat, drink, dance, be merry and make someone somewhere feel better about themselves. Cheers to my fellow writers![/nq]
Bless your heart, Suzy. Really.

There's nothing more important in making movies than the screenplay. Richard Attenborough
0
[nq:1]Being an American, I annually press my wife for a second turkey day.[/nq]
You do what??
Oh.
"annually"
Never mind.

There's nothing more important in making movies than the screenplay. Richard Attenborough
0
I would like to offer my condolences to all the newsgroupies who have lost loved ones this year and who will be experiencing their first holiday season without their father, brother, or other important relatives and friends.
The first one can be rugged.
Lois
0
[nq:1]I would like to offer my condolences to all the newsgroupies who have lost loved ones this year and who will be experiencing their first holiday season without their father, brother, or other important relatives and friends. The first one can be rugged.[/nq]
And bless your heart, too.

There's nothing more important in making movies than the screenplay. Richard Attenborough
0
[nq:2]Being an American, I annually press my wife for a second turkey day.[/nq]
[nq:1]You do what?? Oh. "annually" Never mind.[/nq]
Thank you for that, MC.
There. I just knew Thanksgiving would have real, utilitarian purpose this year.
Doug
Just a virtual guy... in a virtual world

Related Questions