0
Kooyeen Posted 19 years ago
Grammar

I'm dancing like I was a professional dancer

0 Hi everyone,02br
00let's consider these:01ol
    01li
  1. 00I'm dancing 01u01b00as if I'm02b02u00 a professional dancer.02li
  2. 01li
  3. 00I'm dancing 01u01b00as if I was/were02b02u00 a professional dancer.02li
  4. 01li
  5. 00I'm dancing 01u01b00like I'm02b02u00 a professional dancer.02li
  6. 01li
  7. 00I'm dancing 01b01u00like I was/were02u02b00 a professional dancer.02li
  8. 02ol
00I don't know why, but I feel that #4 is not ok. I feel it doesn't have the same meaning as the others, I feel that after "like" a past tense would actually indicate past tense, and not "hypothetical present".02br
00And I don't know why, but I also feel that #1 is not as good as #2. I feel that "as if" sounds better with a past tense (which act like an "hypothetical present").02br
00To summarize, #2 and #3 are the idiomatic ones, #1 is ok but less idiomatic, and structure #4 is not used (if used it'd have a different meaning, "was" would refer to the past).02br
02br
00Do you feel the same? Thank you in advance 050010id1
  

Top answer

0I would say # 2 and 4 are the correct ones, 02br 02br 00'as if' implies an unreal state, therefore you should use a past tense (refer to 2nd and 3rd conditionals)02br 02br 00Normally a noun is used after 'like', and not a clause (a sentence), but i guess it can be said and it would be informal or colloquial English0-

  • 0I would say # 2 and 4 are the correct ones, 02br 02br 00'as if' implies an unreal state, therefore you should use a past tense (refer to 2nd and 3rd conditionals)02br 02br 00Normally a noun is used after 'like', and not a clause (a sentence), but i guess it can be said and it would be informal or colloquial English0-
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
0I would say # 2 and 4 are the correct ones, 02br
02br
00'as if' implies an unreal state, therefore you should use a past tense (refer to 2nd and 3rd conditionals)02br
02br
00Normally a noun is used after 'like', and not a clause (a sentence), but i guess it can be said and it would be informal or colloquial English0-
0
0 Hi Marcelle,01blockquote
01cite10Marcelle12cite10I would say # 2 and 4 are the correct ones, 12br
10'as if' implies an unreal state, therefore 11font10you should use a past tense12font10 (refer to 2nd and 3rd conditionals) 11font10Yeah, but present tenses are fi
0
0 01ol
    01li
  1. 00I'm dancing 01u01b00as if I'm02b02u00 a professional dancer.02li
  2. 01li
  3. 00I'm dancing 01u01b00as if I was/were02b02u00 a professional dancer.02li
  4. 01li
  5. 00I'm dancing 01u01b00like I'm02b02u00 a professional dancer.02

Related Questions