0
Gamboler Posted 11 years ago
Vocabulary

If I say the contrary...

Is it correct?

If I say that I don't care, I will look rude. And if I say the contrary [opposite], too.

This is what I want to mean: If I say "I don't care", I'll look rude, if I say "I care", I'll look rude, too. Does the first sentence (the one in bold type) have sense just putting the word too at the end? Is there a better way to express the same idea?
  

Top answer

It depends on the tone of voice and the context: Waiter: Do you want peas or carrots as your vegetable? Roberto: I don't care. I like both vegetables.

  • It depends on the tone of voice and the context: Waiter: Do you want peas or carrots as your vegetable?
  • Roberto: I don't care.
  • I like both vegetables.
  • Which do you recommend?
  • Mother: If you don't eat all your peas, little children will stave in India.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
It depends on the tone of voice and the context:

Waiter: Do you want peas or carrots as your vegetable?
Roberto: I don't care. I like both vegetables. Which do you recommend?

Mother: If you don't eat all your peas, little children will stave in India.
Rude child: I don't care! I hate peas!

I cannot think of a context where "I care." is rude.
0
AlpheccaStars, thanks, but it was not my doubt.

I didn't want to know if saying "I don't care" is rude or not. My question was about the grammar of the sentence, especially if I can place the word too at the end ommiting the rest, as indicated.

The sentence is: "If I say I don't care, I'll look rude, and if I say the contrary, too" (meaning that if I say the oppos
0
The real problem here is that there isn't really an opposite to a simple "I don't care", "I care" is not used in that way.
0
Ok, fivejedjon. I understand your point.

But, look, I need a fine translation of the sentence implying that "if he says it's important for him" (not that "he cares"), the other person would think he's rude too. It's the subtitle of a movie, I can't change the words, just try to find a good translation having sense in English.
0
Look at this paragraph:

"I just don't care. I was recently listening to a friend lament the fact that he hadn't bought new clothes in a long time and, as such, he felt he wasn't dressing well. For most people, this would have been a cue to reassure him that he looked just fine. But Friend Number 2, who is one of the most authentically truthful people I know, cocked her head and asked,
0
gambolerI googled the web and found it a minute ago, so somebody uses "I did care" in spite of what you said.
If you care to believe that"I care" is used as the oppositerof "I don't care"as a response to something that's said, fine. I see little point, however, in my offering any further thoughts on this.
0
If I say that I don't care, I will look rude. And also if I say the contrary [opposite].
0
gambolerIs it correct? If I say that I don't care, I will look rude. And if I say the contrary [opposite], too.
No. There's something wrong there. It might be a little better with "... the opposite as well", but I think most natives would rephrase as:

I'll look rude whether I say X or not X, i.e.,

I'll look rude whether I say I care or I

Related Questions