0
Pructus Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

I wish I were

Hi, Forum Gurus and Members!

(A) I wish I were a bird that could fly. VS (B) I wish I were a bird that can fly.

*** *** ***

Among (A) and (B), which is correct? Or both are correct?
  

Top answer

Are you an ostrich? Why have you added 'that can/could fly'? That makes the sentence so strange that it is hard to focus on your question.

  • Are you an ostrich?
  • Why have you added 'that can/could fly'?
  • That makes the sentence so strange that it is hard to focus on your question.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

10 Answers
0
Are you an ostrich? Why have you added 'that can/could fly'? That makes the sentence so strange that it is hard to focus on your question.
0
pructus
(A) I wish I were a bird that could fly. VS (B) I wish I were a bird that can fly.

*** *** ***
Between (A) and (B), which is correct? Or are both correct?
(A) is correct, but sounds a bit odd as most birds can fly and I take it you wouldn't want to be a fli
0
Thanks everybody!!

If the sentence sounds unnatural, how about changing it into:

He wishes he were a genius that could/can solve any mathematics problems.
0
he wishes he were a genius that could solve any mathematical problem.
0
Better! And as Rover has already indicated:

He wishes he were a genius who could solve any mathematics problem.
0
What about saying " I wish I was " instead of " I wish I were " is it correct or incorrect?
0
What about saying " I wish I was " instead of " I wish I were " is it correct or incorrect?
0
Thanks again, Mister Micawber....

I wonder how this sounds to your ear? Simply ungrammatical or sounds reasonable but less refined?

"He wishes he were a genius who can solve any mathematics problem."
0
What about saying " I wish I was " instead of " I wish I were " is it correct or incorrect?-- It is accepted informally.

He wishes he were a genius who can solve any mathematics problem. -- It just sounds a little 'off' to me, actually. What happens is that the subjunctive 'were' activates the tendency to regress 'can' to 'could', so that 'could' becomes the e
0
Thanks Mister Micawber!!

Related Questions