0
Anonymous Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

"I have always" or "I always"?

Hello,

what's correct "I have always hated you" or "I always hated you"?
  

Top answer

Both are correct, with different meanings. "I have always hated you" In the past right up to now. I still hate you.

  • Both are correct, with different meanings.
  • "I have always hated you" In the past right up to now.
  • I still hate you.
  • "I always hated you" eg until I fell in love with you last Friday.
  • Clive
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

11 Answers
0
Both are correct, with different meanings.

"I have always hated you" In the past right up to now. I still hate you.


"I always hated you" eg until I fell in love with you last Friday.

Clive
0
Thanks. I understand that both are correct, but I still don't really know when to use which one. For example, if I use it in a sentence, "I have aways hated you for being stubborn" or "I always hated you for being stubborn", which would you prefer?
0
AnonymousWhich is correct?
0
When I say "I always hated you", doesn't it mean that I still hate you?
0
No.
In that case, say 'I have always hated you'.

Clive
0
Hello Clive,

sorry, I still don't understand the difference. Why doesn't it say that I still hate something? For example, when I do a google search for "I always hated Windows", I come up with sentences like "I always hated Windows Media Center ever since I used it in Vista." Doesn't this person still hate it?
0
Some native speakers use the past tense when the present perfect is more appropriate, so I always hated you might be said when I have always hated you is meant. The same applies to your Google search example.
0
So basically I can use both in the same context and there isn't a difference? It's so confusing. In my language, only the equivalent of "I have always hated you" is used.
0
AnonymousSo basically I can use both in the same context and there isn't a difference?
If the context is an applicable one, yes. (See Clive's post above.)
0
So in turn this means "I have always hated you until I fell in love with you last friday" is wrong?

Related Questions