0
Bugbear Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

I had to go = I should go ?

0Hello, according my English teacher, it can be same :02br
00 I had to go = I should go 02br
00 Is it possible?02br
00 Thank you 0-
  

Top answer

0No, it's not possible in normal contexts. Perhaps if you give us some long sentences, it just might be at least theoretically possible in some contexts. 05002br 00CB 010id1

  • 0No, it's not possible in normal contexts.
  • Perhaps if you give us some long sentences, it just might be at least theoretically possible in some contexts.
  • 05002br 00CB 010id1
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

16 Answers
0
0No, it's not possible in normal contexts. Perhaps if you give us some long sentences, it just might be at least theoretically possible in some contexts. In English virtually anything is possible!05002br
00CB 010id1
0
0Situation: while chating with somebody, an other person arrives at somebody's home and the somebody writes to you " here is an other person,01b00 I had to go02b00 "02br
00It's not the easiest way to write down the situation 05000 Anyway, Is there any mistake in my sentece above (situation)?010id1
0
0 01blockquote
01cite10bugbear12cite10Situation: while chating with somebody, an other person arrives at somebody's home and the somebody writes to you " here is an other person,11b10 I had to go12b10 "12br
12br
12blockquote
10I am not sure I understand your sentence correctly but if I do, I wo
0
0Sorry, I don't know what's happening with my computer.02br
02br
00Anyway, as far as I know, "had to" is the past form of "have to".02br
02br
00HAVE TO is usually used to show an obligation, while SHOULD shows something that you are supposed/expected to do (or an advisable action) but you might not choose to do it (with your own risk!).02br
02br
0
1blockquote
01cite10bugbear12cite10Situation: while chating with somebody, an other person arrives at somebody's home and the somebody writes to you " here is an other 11b10person, I had to go12b10 " 12br
12br
10It's not 11del10the easiest way12del10 easy to write down the 11del
0
0Oops. There are many mistakes 05000 Apart from this, thank you Yoong and I02br
00will try to pay attention to write correct sentences. 02br
00So I know how to use "have to" , that's why I wrote my problem down.02br
00Anyway my teacher is a native speaker of English. He ususally lives 02br
00in London but now he has been working here for 1 y
0
0I think you're mixing up present and past tense. 02br
02br
00 You have to = You should (as a general rule), there is still a small difference. "You have to" is stronger, and "You should" is more of a suggestion.02br
02br
00 When you change them to past tense, "I had to" and "I should (have)", there is a significant difference I wouldn't compare as being
0
0 No, I am not mixing up present and past tense at all.02br
00Don't compare "had to" with "should". This sentence is special, of course according my teacher: "I had to go" you can ONLY use with GO in this case. In other ways it means past tense. 0-
0
0I should go02br
00means02br
00I ought to go 02br
00and can relate only to02br
00I have to go (as it is related to present time)02br
02br
00and NOT to02br
00I had to go (which is past: I was forced/obliged to go)02br
02br
00BUT: 01i00I should go02i00 is softer than 01i
0
1blockquote
01cite10Cool Breeze12cite12br
11i10Had to go12i10 is past tense: 11i10I 11b10had12b10 to go there 11b10yesterday.12b12i12br
12br
12blockquote
10Maybe I have too luxuriant an imagination, but this is how I see it:02br

Related Questions