0
Sitifan Posted 10 years ago
Grammar

I am a Chinese.

1. I am a Chinese.
2. I am Chinese.
Are the above sentences both correct?
  

Top answer

I dislike (1). (2) is fine. By the way, this may not be relevant, but I see that you are from Taiwan.

  • I dislike (1).
  • (2) is fine.
  • By the way, this may not be relevant, but I see that you are from Taiwan.
  • If you simply say "I am Chinese", I think that most English speakers by default would think that you were from mainland China.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

23 Answers
0
I dislike (1). (2) is fine.

By the way, this may not be relevant, but I see that you are from Taiwan. If you simply say "I am Chinese", I think that most English speakers by default would think that you were from mainland China.
0
People in Western countries very seldom say eg He is a Chinese..
They say
eg He's Chinese.
eg He's a Chinese person.
0
ClivePeople in Western countries very seldom say eg He is a Chinese.
I would like to agree with you. Unfortunately I seem to hear this kind of abomination more and more often these days.
0
sitifan1. I am a Chinese.2. I am Chinese.Are the above sentences both correct?
The sentences are not good. We don't know if you are a citizen of China or an ethnic chinese person or both.
0
Why do you find it an abomination?
Do you also abhor eg He's an Italian?
0
'A Chinese' is derogatory verging on racist.
0
How about I'm Irish? Emotion: wink
0
And therefore lucky I guess, but are you disputing my comment?
0
Vic Z And therefore lucky I guess, but are you disputing my comment?
Shouldn't you all please continue the discussion in the "Controversial Topics" section?
0
I wondered if you might object to I'm Irish on the grounds that it is unclear whether it refers to nationality or ethnicity.

I've never thought of He's a Chinese as derogatory. Many of my Chinese students have said it to me.

Clive

Related Questions