0
Avangi Posted 17 years ago
Grammar
He might say it in fun.
Hi,
I just used this in a post, referring to my grandfather, who died forty years ago. I don't know if I'll ever learn the ins and outs of modals. To my ear, it sounds fine, but it does seem strange when you think about it.
I didn't want to use, "He might have said it in fun," because that would seem to refer to a particular occasion. My intention was to refer to the habits of a deceased person.
Any guidance on this?? << He might say it in fun. >>
Best wishes, - A.
I just used this in a post, referring to my grandfather, who died forty years ago. I don't know if I'll ever learn the ins and outs of modals. To my ear, it sounds fine, but it does seem strange when you think about it.
I didn't want to use, "He might have said it in fun," because that would seem to refer to a particular occasion. My intention was to refer to the habits of a deceased person.
Any guidance on this?? << He might say it in fun. >>
Best wishes, - A.
Top answer
"He might have said it in fun" I don't see anything wrong with this formulation. Given the context of your original post I would not have taken it to mean a specific occasion. In fact your revised version here is better than the original.
- "He might have said it in fun" I don't see anything wrong with this formulation.
- Given the context of your original post I would not have taken it to mean a specific occasion.
- In fact your revised version here is better than the original.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
3 Answers
0
"He might have said it in fun"
I don't see anything wrong with this formulation. Given the context of your original post I would not have taken it to mean a specific occasion. In fact your revised version here is better than the original.
I don't see anything wrong with this formulation. Given the context of your original post I would not have taken it to mean a specific occasion. In fact your revised version here is better than the original.
00
Avangi it does seem strange when you think about it.Not to me. A little old-fashioned, maybe, but I like it.
AvangiAny guidance on this?? << He might say it in fun. >>A (fairly rare) case of might as the past tense of may, I'd say (in the intended reading).
Back in the old days, the
00
Related Questions