0
Usenet Posted 23 years ago
Usage

He isn't vs. He's not

I'm not a native speaker and I was wondering about whether or not I can use

No, he's not.
instead of
No, he isn't.
Are both versions perfectly acceptable in short answers? Markus
  

Top answer

[nq:1]I'm not a native speaker and I was wondering about whether or not I can use No, he's not. instead of No, he isn't. Are both versions perfectly acceptable in short answers?

  • [nq:1]I'm not a native speaker and I was wondering about whether or not I can use No, he's not.
  • instead of No, he isn't.
  • Are both versions perfectly acceptable in short answers?
  • Markus[/nq] Yes, to my ear.
  • Perhaps there's regional variation on this, but nothing I've ever noticed.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

12 Answers
0
[nq:1]I'm not a native speaker and I was wondering about whether or not I can use No, he's not. instead of No, he isn't. Are both versions perfectly acceptable in short answers? Markus[/nq]
Yes, to my ear. Perhaps there's regional variation on this, but nothing I've ever noticed. I can't think of much of a difference in meaning or emphasis, either, just the rhythm.
Same applies for "They'r
0
[nq:1]I'm not a native speaker and I was wondering about whether or not I can use No, he's not. instead of No, he isn't. Are both versions perfectly acceptable in short answers?[/nq]
Yes both are fine, although in the specific case where you wanted to emphasise the negative, you probably choose "he is not".

Alison
0
[nq:1]I'm not a native speaker and I was wondering about whether or not I canuse No, he's not. instead of No, he isn't. Are both versions perfectly acceptable in short answers?[/nq]
Yes. (There is regional variation. I associate the "He's not"-type with Scotland and the north of England.)
Adrian
0
[nq:1]I'm not a native speaker and I was wondering about whether or not I can use No, he's not. instead of No, he isn't. Are both versions perfectly acceptable in short answers? Markus[/nq]
Yes. And they mean exactly the same thing. There's a difference in style, emphasis, and what they rhyme with.
0
Strange. I think you could do some more research. I have never noticed any regional variation, nor could I predict with certainty which of the two forms I would use in any given situation.

Rob Bannister
0
[nq:2]use Yes. (There is regional variation. I associate the "He's not"-type with Scotland and the north of England.)[/nq]
[nq:1]Strange. I think you could do some more research. I have never noticed any regional variation, nor could I predict with certainty which of the two forms I would use in any given situation.[/nq]
It might be worth mentioning that in Gaelic, as spoken in Scotland an
0
[nq:2]use Yes. (There is regional variation. I associate the "He's not"-typewith Scotland and the north of England.)[/nq]
[nq:1]Strange. I think you could do some more research. I have nevernoticed any regional variation, nor could I predict with certainty which ofthe two forms I would use in any given situation.[/nq]
I think I (from Sheffield) would prefer "He's not" in most circumstances
0
[nq:2]Yes. (There is regional variation. I associate the "He's not"-type with Scotland and the north of England.)[/nq]
[nq:1]Strange. I think you could do some more research. I have never noticed any regional variation, nor could I predict with certainty which of the two forms I would use in any given situation.[/nq]
Around my neck of the north of England (Wet Yorks/Lancs) the "'s not" typ
0
[nq:2]Strange. I think you could do some more research. I ... the two forms I would use in any given situation.[/nq]
[nq:1]I think I (from Sheffield) would prefer "He's not" in most circumstances, but I don't know whether this is regional.[/nq]
See, I knew I should have read more of the thread. I think it's regional, and it's definitely common in Yorks/Lancs. As a nancy southerner I still
0
[nq:2]use Yes. (There is regional variation. I associate the "He's not"-type with Scotland and the north of England.)[/nq]
[nq:1]Strange. I think you could do some more research. I have never noticed any regional variation, nor could I predict with certainty which of the two forms I would use in any given situation.[/nq]
I agree entirely. It would be a matter of whim.

wrmst rgrds

Related Questions