0
Sundarnaz Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

Having been

In spite of the English language having been thrown into the background, some works were composed in it.

Why "having been", why not "have been"?

  

Top answer

In spite of the English language having been thrown into the background , some works were composed in it. "In spite of" + NP + gerund-participial clause is one of a large number of idiomatic expressions in English. In short, there is no alternative to using a gerund-participial clause (or an NP of course) as complement to "of", and hence the perfect "have been" is impossible here.

  • In spite of the English language having been thrown into the background , some works were composed in it.
  • "In spite of" + NP + gerund-participial clause is one of a large number of idiomatic expressions in English.
  • In short, there is no alternative to using a gerund-participial clause (or an NP of course) as complement to "of", and hence the perfect "have been" is impossible here.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

In spite of the English language having been thrown into the background, some works were composed in it.

"In spite of" + NP + gerund-participial clause is one of a large number of idiomatic expressions in English. In short, there is no alternative to using a gerund-participial clause (or an NP of course) as complement to "of", and hence the perfect "have been" is impossibl

Related Questions