0
Kaos Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Have/Had

0Could you help me with this, please?02br
00Imagine a scenario where a token is passed to the other end. In response, the other end returns a color hint, which is either black or white. When the token sender receives a white, it knows immediately that the other end must already 01u01b00have/had02b02u00 the token. 02br
00Should it be have or had?0-
  

Top answer

0Hi Kaos,02br 02br 00Must .... "02br 02br 00You 01i 00must be 02i 00tired. He 01i 00must go02i 00 see his mothers.

  • 0Hi Kaos,02br 02br 00Must ....
  • "02br 02br 00You 01i 00must be 02i 00tired.
  • He 01i 00must go02i 00 see his mothers.
  • 02br 02br 00(I'm not sure I understand the rest of what you've written, though.
  • Passed to the other end of what?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
0Hi Kaos,02br
02br
00Must .... have.02br
02br
00After must, use the "bare infinitive" - that is, the "to X" form of the verb without the "to."02br
02br
00You 01i00must be 02i00tired. He 01i00must go02i00 see his mothers. They 01i00must have 02i00the token.02br
0
0Thank you for your quick reply, Grammar Geek :-)02br
00The 01i00other end02i00 is a 01i00receiver02i00.02br
00Someone suggested to me -- 01b00have had02b02br
02br
00Is that correct too?0-
0
0No, that to me sounds like they had it BEFORE this whole process began, which isn't right.0-
0
0 01i00have had02i02br
00is correct grammatically, but it generates confusion (he received the token, then he lost it, perhaps)0-
0
0Thank you Geek and Hancu for clarifying :-)02br
00One last question. Is the following modified text correct? 02br
00Imagine a scenario where a token is passed to a receiver at one end. In response, the receiver returns a color hint, which is either black or white. When the token sender receives a white, it knows immediately that the token 01del00must02
0
0Imagine a scenario where a token is passed to a receiver at one end. In response, the receiver returns a color hint, which is either black or white. When the token sender receives a white, 01b00he02b00 knows (or they know) immediately that the token has been received by the receiver.02br
02br
00(If the person getting it doesn't send a signal until he g
0
0Thank you again. Suppose that the sender is a machine or a robot. Is it wrong to use 01b00it02b00 instead of 01b00he/they02b00? 01blockquote
01cite10Grammar Geek12cite10(If the person getting it doesn't send a signal until he gets it, does it matter if he sends "white" or "black"?) 12blockquote

Related Questions