0
Dita Posted 21 years ago
Grammar
Have you given Helen.....
Hi,
in sentence
DID YOU GIVE / HAVE YOU GIVEN Helen my message when you HAVE SEEN / SAW her?
Correct is DID YOU GIVE and SAW but why?
thanks
Dita
in sentence
DID YOU GIVE / HAVE YOU GIVEN Helen my message when you HAVE SEEN / SAW her?
Correct is DID YOU GIVE and SAW but why?
thanks
Dita
Top answer
The second clause indicates a specific, single past event, therefore the main clause will not take present perfect, since it is thereby also set in the completed past.
- The second clause indicates a specific, single past event, therefore the main clause will not take present perfect, since it is thereby also set in the completed past.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
1 Answers
0
The second clause indicates a specific, single past event, therefore the main clause will not take present perfect, since it is thereby also set in the completed past.
0
Related Questions