Suppose ‘you ’ have gone to India and are in now and are talking with ‘me’ over the phone. ‘I’ am in the and asking ‘you ’ as the two sentences in my second post (the post at 08:52 PM).
In the situation above, I think “Have you gone to India?” means “Are you in India
No, and if 'India' means 'India ink' and the conversation is about changing one's medium of artistic expression, they do not mean the same either. Which demonstrates that it is senseless to present statements out of context which you wish to consider in a context. It wastes all of our time, and mine is particularly valuable.