0
Yellowstarstruck Posted 6 years ago
Grammar

Have you ever?

Hi! Are 1 and 2 the same meaning? Are 3 and 4 the same meaning? Also 5 and 6. Thanks, Fulvio

1 Have you ever been on a horse?

2 Have you ever ridden a horse?

3 Have you ever been on a train?

4 Have you ever ridden a train?

5 Have you ever been on a helicopter?

6 Have you ever ridden on a helicopter?

  

Top answer

Within each pair the meaning is different. You have been on a horse, a train, or a helicopter even if the horse, train, or helicopter was not moving. Suppose you went to a museum which had a space shuttle that was no longer in service.

  • Within each pair the meaning is different.
  • You have been on a horse, a train, or a helicopter even if the horse, train, or helicopter was not moving.
  • Suppose you went to a museum which had a space shuttle that was no longer in service.
  • Suppose, as part of a tour, you were allowed to go inside that space shuttle, and you did.
  • Now you can say that you were on a space shuttle, but not that you have ridden on a space shuttle.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

Within each pair the meaning is different.

You have been on a horse, a train, or a helicopter even if the horse, train, or helicopter was not moving.

Suppose you went to a museum which had a space shuttle that was no longer in service. Suppose, as part of a tour, you were allowed to go inside that space shuttle, and you did.

Now you can say that you were on a space sh

Related Questions