Have vs Having;

Question

Our Head Mistress always says, “You are having an exam this afternoon.” But I think, the following sentence is correct; “You have an exam this afternoon.”

H.M: “You are having Science period after an hour”

Me: “You have a Science period after an hour.”

H.M: “Children! you are having essay writing competition in the 3rd Period.:

Me: “Children! you have an essay writing competition in the 3rd period.:

I would appreciate if somebody could correct the above sentences.

Mister Micawber · Accepted Answer

You're having an exam this afternoon.

You have an exam this afternoon.

You're having Science period after an hour.

You have a Science period after an hour.

Children! You're having essay writing competition in the 3rd Period.

Children! You have an essay writing competition in the 3rd period.

Both forms are acceptable in all cases. The standard is 'you have'. 'You are having' carries a note of heightened interest or concern by the speaker.

JohnParis · Answer

Our Head Mistress always says, “You are having an exam this afternoon.” But I think, the following sentence is correct; “You have an exam this afternoon.” Both sentences are correct.

H.M: “You are having Science period after an hour” You will have, you will be having, you are going to have Science period in an hour.

Me: “You have a Science period after an hour.” You will have, you are having, you are going to have Science period in an hour.”

H.M: “Children! you are having essay writing competition in the 3rd Period.: Children! you will have, you are having, you are going to have an essay writing competition in the 3rd Period

Me: “Children! you have an essay writing competition in the 3rd period.: Correct

I would appreciate if somebody could correct the above sentences.

Mr. Micawber is also correct. I have chosen to use various forms of the future for additional clarity.

I hope this helps (more than confuses)

Have vs Having;

Top answer

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

Related Questions