0
IronHelix Posted 21 years ago
Grammar

has has

Since the only meaning of “has” in the dictionary is the third person singular present of have, then what meaning would “has has” have in a sentence such as:

“The defendant has has not been convicted of any other domestic violence offense”
  

Top answer

Is the statement, perhaps, a quotation from a st-stut-stuttering la-law-lawyer?

  • Is the statement, perhaps, a quotation from a st-stut-stuttering la-law-lawyer?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

26 Answers
0
Is the statement, perhaps, a quotation from a st-stut-stuttering la-law-lawyer?
0
Hi IronHelix and welcome to EnglishForward,

It is probably because the noun "have" is the superordinate word (hypernym)of the words such as person, individual, someone, somebody, mortal, human, soul.

“The defendant has has not been convicted of any other domestic violence offense”

“The defendant person / individual has not been convicte
0
Hallo IronHelix,

there is a tiny mistake there:

The defendant has / has not been convicted of any other domestic violence offense.

You are given two alternatives.

rgds,

cairn

BTW: third person singular present of have is not meaning but verb form.
0
I don't get what you meant, yulysess. Could you elaborate on that, please?
0
Hi cairn,

Could you please rephrase the sentence?
0
Wow, Yulysess! That has got to be one of the wildest and whackiest speculations I've ever read on EnglishForward.
0
the sentence IronHelix wrote up
0
Hi Cairn,

“The defendant (has/ has not) been convicted of any other domestic violence offense.”

Yeh, I thought of that one possibility. It wouldn't be the first time that a questioner's quotation includes a typo, or an omission.

But then IronHelix also says 'a sentence such as' as if others like it have been seen.

And besides, where would such a s
0
Hello davkett,

yup, it can be misleading.

yulysses: it is a fixed phrase. Imagine that you get a form to fill in where you find these two alternatives to choose from:

I have been convicted of a domestic violence offense.

I have not been convicted of a domestic violence offense.

(just put a tick next to the appropria

Related Questions