0
OttoJ Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

Has broken/broke

-Former US President George HW Bush has broken a bone in his neck during a fall at his home.

It sounds OK but I'm not sure whether during a fall is like yesterday, which requires the simple past. Do you think has broken is wrong?
  

Top answer

OttoJ Do you think has broken is wrong? No; it is news item stating an event: events commonly take present perfect. Present perfect also indicates a recent event, and news likes to be recent.

  • OttoJ Do you think has broken is wrong?
  • No; it is news item stating an event: events commonly take present perfect.
  • Present perfect also indicates a recent event, and news likes to be recent.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
OttoJ Do you think has broken is wrong?
No; it is news item stating an event: events commonly take present perfect. Present perfect also indicates a recent event, and news likes to be recent.

Related Questions