0
Usenet Posted 16 years ago
Usage
Harry Potter and the Crock of
Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and without dramatic tension?
Harry Potter films don't have a vision of reality. There are no laws; "anything goes". So there are no real, true-grit plots, no solid archetypal themes, no death, no life... all is ham performance where consequences are like vapours.
The Harry Potter Universe is a montage patched from a limited number of bad-taste sources.
These sources include glum Christian Halloween horror kitsch with its pagan mockery; and an ageing, yet still tiresome, western stage magic, complete with rabbits and hats. A strong influence is the old American TV series "Bewitched", where things and people vanish and appear, and vanish again, with a twinkle of the eye, a wriggle of the nose, or a waving of some bloody silly stick.
Harry Potter - it's less than ho-hum.
Harry Potter films don't have a vision of reality. There are no laws; "anything goes". So there are no real, true-grit plots, no solid archetypal themes, no death, no life... all is ham performance where consequences are like vapours.
The Harry Potter Universe is a montage patched from a limited number of bad-taste sources.
These sources include glum Christian Halloween horror kitsch with its pagan mockery; and an ageing, yet still tiresome, western stage magic, complete with rabbits and hats. A strong influence is the old American TV series "Bewitched", where things and people vanish and appear, and vanish again, with a twinkle of the eye, a wriggle of the nose, or a waving of some bloody silly stick.
Harry Potter - it's less than ho-hum.
Top answer
[nq:1]Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and without dramatic tension? Harry Potter films don't have a vision ... a wriggle of the nose, or a waving of some ****** silly stick.
- [nq:1]Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and without dramatic tension?
- Harry Potter films don't have a vision ...
- a wriggle of the nose, or a waving of some ****** silly stick.
- [/nq] Are the Harry Potter books really amenable to philosophical analysis?
- Philosophy and literature certainly go hand-in-hand, so the answer to this question probably turns on whether you think the Harry Potter books qualify as any sort of literature or are merely =93junk food=94 on paper.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
106 Answers
0
[nq:1]Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and without dramatic tension? Harry Potter films don't have a vision ... a wriggle of the nose, or a waving of some ****** silly stick. Harry Potter - it's less than ho-hum.[/nq]
Are the Harry Potter books really amenable to philosophical analysis? Philosophy and literature certainly go hand-in-hand, so the answer to this question probably
Are the Harry Potter books really amenable to philosophical analysis? Philosophy and literature certainly go hand-in-hand, so the answer to this question probably
00
[nq:1]Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and without dramatic tension?[/nq]
Cos it's for children maybe?
Cos it's for children maybe?
00
[nq:1]Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and without dramatic tension? Harry Potter films don't have a vision of reality.[/nq]
That sentence shows how devoid of imagination and intelligence you are.
You actually show that you have less of these qualities than the teenagers to which these movies/novels are for.
Shame on you.
Olrik
That sentence shows how devoid of imagination and intelligence you are.
You actually show that you have less of these qualities than the teenagers to which these movies/novels are for.
Shame on you.
Olrik
00
[nq:1]Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and without dramatic tension? Harry Potter films don't have a vision ... a wriggle of the nose, or a waving of some ****** silly stick. Harry Potter - it's less than ho-hum.[/nq]
Good post, John. Children are indoctrinated into mystical beliefs from the time they're in the crib. It's one reason why so many people know so little about scien
Good post, John. Children are indoctrinated into mystical beliefs from the time they're in the crib. It's one reason why so many people know so little about scien
00
(Email Removed):
[nq:1]The Harry Potter books are not Shakespeare, but they do address serious themes and Rowling's ability to tackle them in interesting ways is, I think, an important reason for why the books are popular.[/nq]
Whether JK Rowling's Harry Potter books are "literature" or not is uninportant if you drop by your local library or middle school library and pick one up in your ha
[nq:1]The Harry Potter books are not Shakespeare, but they do address serious themes and Rowling's ability to tackle them in interesting ways is, I think, an important reason for why the books are popular.[/nq]
Whether JK Rowling's Harry Potter books are "literature" or not is uninportant if you drop by your local library or middle school library and pick one up in your ha
00
[nq:2]Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and ... ****** silly stick. Harry Potter - it's less than ho-hum.[/nq]
[nq:1]Are the Harry Potter books really amenable to philosophical analysis? Philosophy and literature certainly go hand-in-hand, so the answer to ... alternate realities, forcing us to use our imaginations and consider how our own world might be different. http://atheis
[nq:1]Are the Harry Potter books really amenable to philosophical analysis? Philosophy and literature certainly go hand-in-hand, so the answer to ... alternate realities, forcing us to use our imaginations and consider how our own world might be different. http://atheis
00
[nq:1]Now you can read my post.[/nq]
There's not much there to read.
TehGhodTrole: Trolling, for ***'s sake.
There's not much there to read.
TehGhodTrole: Trolling, for ***'s sake.
00
[nq:1]Good post, John. Children are indoctrinated into mystical beliefs from the time they're in the crib. It's one reason why ... if they feature a scientist or mathematician or professor in a movie, he's either a nutcase or a secret avenger.[/nq]
Dude, watch "The Core". It'll cure you of your desire to see scientists portrayed as heroes.
Mike
Dude, watch "The Core". It'll cure you of your desire to see scientists portrayed as heroes.
Mike
00
[nq:1]Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and without dramatic tension?You are bias. Harry Potter films don't have ... twinkle of the eye, a wriggle of the nose, or a waving of some ****** silly stick.Well, entertaining isn't it?[/nq]
At least it did not lie and did not ask for donation for survival.
At least it did not lie and did not ask for donation for survival.
00
[nq:2]Why do I find Harry Potter films glum, soulless, and ... ****** silly stick. Harry Potter - it's less than ho-hum.[/nq]
[nq:1]Good post, John. Children are indoctrinated into mystical beliefs from the time they're in the crib. It's one reason why ... if they feature a scientist or mathematician or professor in a movie, he's either a nutcase or a secret avenger.[/nq]
Kinsey!!
[nq:1]Good post, John. Children are indoctrinated into mystical beliefs from the time they're in the crib. It's one reason why ... if they feature a scientist or mathematician or professor in a movie, he's either a nutcase or a secret avenger.[/nq]
Kinsey!!
0
Related Questions