0
Makabi Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

had or not?

I want to know which one is right and why. The sentence is refering about things in the past.

1. A man had died and we just laughed about it.

2. A man died and we just laughed about it. (also is there ''just" in that one?)

3. A man had died and we were laughing about it.

4. A man died and we were laughing about it.
  

Top answer

Makabi I want to know which one is right and why. 1. 2.

  • Makabi I want to know which one is right and why.
  • 1.
  • 2.
  • A man died and we just laughed about it.
  • )3.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

26 Answers
0
MakabiI want to know which one is right and why. The sentence is refering about to things in the past.1. A man had died and we just laughed about it.2. A man died and we just laughed about it. (also is there ''just" in that one?)3. A man had died and we were laughing about it.4. A man died and we were laughing abou
0
So all of them can be used?
0
They are all grammatically correct, but would be used with differing time references, slight changes in meaning.
0
MakabiI want to know which one is right and why. The sentence is refering about things in the past.1. A man had died and we just laughed about it.2. A man died and we just laughed about it. (also is there ''just" in that one?)3. A man had died and we were laughing about it.4. A man died and we were laughing about it.
They are all possible, but 1 and 3 contain
0
I'd like to ask if I change some of the words in the following text, will the text still be gramatically correct?

Saint-Mars's other prisoners at Pignerol included Count http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ercole_Antonio_Mattioli (or Matthioli), an Italian diplomat who
0
Makabiwill the text still be grammatically correct?
Yes. It doesn't take much to make a sentence grammatically correct.
0
I want to ask which is the right one and why.

1. If I had the chance I would butcher them.

2. If I had the chance I will butcher them.

I think it's 1.
0
MakabiI think it's 1.
It is.

The three most used patterns for if-statements are:

IF present-tense, WILL {INF}
IF past-tense, WOULD {INF}
IF ... HAD {PP}, WOULD HAVE {PP}

{INF} = plain infinitive (no "to")
{PP} = past participle

CJ
0
So if I say:

1. If I wanted to butcher them I would have stayed.

2. If I want to butcher them I will stay.

Both of them would be right, and when I cross-use them, the meaning wouldn't be that much different.

Also another question, should I use 'would be right' or 'will be right' in the colored sentence?
0
Makabi1. If I wanted to butcher them I would have stayed.2. If I want to butcher them I will stay.
Technically, it should be If I had wanted to ..., I would have ...on the first one, but you'll hear it as you've written it.
Makabiwhen I cross-use them, the meaning wouldn't be that much different.
The difference is ten

Related Questions