0
Vkr6078 Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

Had or Had had

I had so much respect for him before I read about him.

or I had had so much respect for him before I read about him.

Which is correct ?
  

Top answer

You don't really need the past perfect form - had had - there, though it wouldn't be wrong. The past simple "had" is OK, because in situations like those, the 'past simple' is usually the more natural choice, since the order of the events is made clear by the words such as "after" or as in your "before".

  • You don't really need the past perfect form - had had - there, though it wouldn't be wrong.
  • The past simple "had" is OK, because in situations like those, the 'past simple' is usually the more natural choice, since the order of the events is made clear by the words such as "after" or as in your "before".
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
You don't really need the past perfect form - had had - there, though it wouldn't be wrong. The past simple "had" is OK, because in situations like those, the 'past simple' is usually the more natural choice, since the order of the events is made clear by the words such as "after" or as in your "before".
0
How about this below sentence.

"The building was evacuated after they found/had found one suspected thing"

Found or had found. Which is correct ? Actually I am very confused. While learning more about tenses, I have recenlty come across we have to use past perfect if any event happens before another past event. So in the first sentence I asked and even this sentence, past perf
0
The building was evacuated after they found/had found one suspected thing.

After they found shows clearly that the finding of one suspected thing.is the first action.

However, I have seen many people use after they had found It is not wrong, however.
0
vkr6078"The building was evacuated after they found/had found one suspected thing"
The underlined part is not natural English. Native speakers say "suspicious item" https://www.ucalgary.ca/emergencyplan/emergency-ins

Related Questions