Had limped vs had been limping
"There were drops of blood on the floor, it looked as if a small wounded creature had limped through the stall."
Could you say "it looked as if a small wounded creature had been limping through the stall" without any difference in meaning?
Top answer
olive file 673 Could you say "it looked as if a small wounded creature had been limping through the stall" without any difference in meaning? Virtually no difference, yes. There is a subtle difference in feel.
- olive file 673 Could you say "it looked as if a small wounded creature had been limping through the stall" without any difference in meaning?
- Virtually no difference, yes.
- There is a subtle difference in feel.
- " This is a comma splice -- an incorrect sentence structure.
- You cannot join independent clauses using only a comma.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
olive file 673Could you say "it looked as if a small wounded creature had been limping through the stall" without any difference in meaning?
Virtually no difference, yes. There is a subtle difference in feel.
olive file 673"There were drops of blood on the floor, it looked as if a small wounded creature had limped through the sta
0olive file 673had limped through the stall
This suggests to me that the creature had gone through the stall from one end to the other all in one trip.
olive file 673had been limping through the stall
This suggests to me that the creature may have limped around randomly in the course of its trip through the stall or
0
Related Questions