0
Jigneshbharati Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

Had had

AFTER THEY STUDIED VERB TENSES ALL WEEK, THE STUDENTS HAD HAD ENOUGH GRAMMAR!

Please check my understanding of the above as I always find it hard to understand "have had or had had" construction

Second action in the past: studied

From that point further in the past happened the first action: had had enough...

First had:auxiliary

Second had: main pp of the verb "have"

Which meaning of "have" is used here: possession or experience?


http://blog.esllibrary.com/2013/12/12/past-perfect-vs-past-perfect-progressive/

  

Top answer

This "have enough" is an idiomatic expression that is used almost exclusively in perfect tenses (or with modals). g. ) "I have had enough" is talking about the present result of past experience -- in effect it is used to describe our state now, and "I had had enough" is likewise used to describe our state at some past time.

  • This "have enough" is an idiomatic expression that is used almost exclusively in perfect tenses (or with modals).
  • g.
  • ) "I have had enough" is talking about the present result of past experience -- in effect it is used to describe our state now, and "I had had enough" is likewise used to describe our state at some past time.
  • In your sentence, the students had "had enough" at the end of the week as a result of their experiences during the week.
  • The combination of tenses in your sentence does not read very well to me.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

This "have enough" is an idiomatic expression that is used almost exclusively in perfect tenses (or with modals). (In other senses it can be used with other tenses; e.g. "I have enough food".)

"I have had enough" is talking about the present result of past experience -- in effect it is used to describe our state now, and "I had had enough" is likewise used to describe our state at some p

Related Questions