0
CJ_B Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

Give up/ Give it up

Which is more appropriate for this situation:

You've tried to do something and failed due to an error outside of your control.

1/. "Ok, I give it up!"
2/. "Ok, I give up!"

I thought it was 2 - but I am being brow beaten into thinking otherwise - which is more appropriate.
  

Top answer

Hi CJB, welcome to the forum. I don't know who is browbeating you but they are wrong. The idiom is 'give up' - definitely without the 'it'.

  • Hi CJB, welcome to the forum.
  • I don't know who is browbeating you but they are wrong.
  • The idiom is 'give up' - definitely without the 'it'.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
Hi CJB, welcome to the forum.

I don't know who is browbeating you but they are wrong. The idiom is 'give up' - definitely without the 'it'.
0
nona the britI don't know who is browbeating you but they are wrong. The idiom is 'give up' - definitely without the 'it'.
I've seen a phrase in an english book about phrasal verbs and it said:

No chocolate for me, thanks. I've given it up.

Why has the author used "it"?
0
MikaelNo chocolate for me, thanks. I've given it up.
it = chocolate.

to give up something edible is to eat it no longer.

If it's plural, you use them, of course.

I don't eat cheese sandwiches anymore. I've given them up.

to give up (no object) is to admit defeat, not to try anymore.

Related Questions