0
Specter Posted 19 years ago
Grammar

Gerund as appositive

Hello,

Gerund is a V-ing that functions as a noun. In this sentence:

"Her job, analyzing data brought in by satellites, is exciting."

The gerund phrase 'analyzing data brought in by satellites' is an appositive modifying 'her job.' Does it mean then, that a gerund may also function as an adjective or is there another way to explain this?



Thanks,

SpecterEmotion: big smile

  

Top answer

On the one hand, it is the whole clause that acts as the appositive modifier. But I see the appositive here as just that-- a noun equated with another noun: Her job is exciting. Analyzing data...

  • On the one hand, it is the whole clause that acts as the appositive modifier.
  • But I see the appositive here as just that-- a noun equated with another noun: Her job is exciting.
  • Analyzing data...
  • is exciting.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

37 Answers
0
On the one hand, it is the whole clause that acts as the appositive modifier. But I see the appositive here as just that-- a noun equated with another noun:

Her job is exciting.
Analyzing data... is exciting.
0
Specter"Her job, analyzing data brought in by satellites, is exciting."

The gerund phrase 'analyzing data brought in by satellites' is an appositive modifying 'her job.' Does it mean then, that a gerund may also function as an adjective or is there
0
Exciting is of course a participle-- no one said it wasn't. However, it must be obvious from the casting, Analyzing data... is exciting, that Analyzing is the subject and must therefore be a nominal form.
0
Whl626
Specter
"Her job, analyzing data brought in by satellites, is exciting."

The gerund phrase 'analyzing data brought in by satellites' is an appositive modifying 'her job.' Does it mean then, that a gerund may also f
0
Mister MicawberAnalyzing is the subject and must therefore be a nominal form.
Mister Micawber is right.
CB
0
The gerund phrase 'analyzing data brought in by satellites' is an appositive modifying 'her job.' Does it mean then, that a gerund may also function as an adjective or is there another way to explain this?
You presuppose that an appositive is an adjective. It's not. It's a noun. And strictly speaking an
0
Yeah, it is actually a combination of 2 sentences.

Her job is analyzing data brought in by satellite.

Her job is exciting.

---> Her job, analyzing data brought in by satellite, is exciting.
0
I think you misunderstood.

(analyzing data brought in by satelite) is a noun phrase. analyzing is a noun like analysis.

Her job, the analysis of data brought in by satellite, is exciting.

The job is not performing an analysis of data, which is what an analyzing job would be, so analyzing is not an adjective. The job cannot actually
0
can u give other ex. of gerund as appositive.....Emotion: stick out tongue
0
Here come an example of using gerund as appositive

His hobby, collecting antique coins, has been kept on for years.

Related Questions