0
Bhikkhu1991 Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Essential or superfluous phrase


Hello,

It is painful because one, who deprives the naturalness of one's body of an organ or organs, cannot behave like a normal person. For example, if only one kidney remains inside one's body, it will have to perform the function of two kidneys. Other examples are one, as a physically abnormal person, becomes incapable of performing hard jobs--like sailors and the police-and becomes incapable of participating in sports--basketball, tennis, badminton, a marathon and so forth.


If the second underlined phrase above ''as a physically abnormal person' in bold is not used, will the first underlined phrase 'cannot behave like a normal person' in bold be represented in context of the whole paragraph? In other words, is the second underlined phrase a superfluity? Please note that the two underlined phrases are referring to the same person.

I hope to hear from you soon.

Thank you.


With best wishes.
  

Top answer

You are right. The paragraph has worse problems than that, however. (Though perhaps it is only that I sense the prejudice behind it).

  • You are right.
  • The paragraph has worse problems than that, however.
  • (Though perhaps it is only that I sense the prejudice behind it).
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
.
You are right. The paragraph has worse problems than that, however. (Though perhaps it is only that I sense the prejudice behind it).
.

Related Questions