0
Book tile 71 Posted 8 years ago
Grammar

Essential appositive

Can I use a relative clause ("that is lying on the table") in between a noun phrase ("The book") and its essential appositive ("an English dictionary") as in:

The book that is lying on the table an English dictionary has 300 pages.

  

Top answer

You need punctuation. The book that is lying on the table comma an English dictionary comma has 300 pages period Some people might quibble that it sounds like the table is a dictionary, but really the intended meaning is clear. Clive

  • You need punctuation.
  • The book that is lying on the table comma an English dictionary comma has 300 pages period Some people might quibble that it sounds like the table is a dictionary, but really the intended meaning is clear.
  • Clive
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0

You need punctuation.

The book that is lying on the table comma an English dictionary comma has 300 pages period

Some people might quibble that it sounds like the table is a dictionary, but really the intended meaning is clear.


Clive

0
book tile 71

Can I use a relative clause ("that is lying on the table") in between a noun phrase ("The book") and its essential appositive ("an English dictionary") as in:

The book that is lying on the table, an English dictionary, has 300 pages.

Related Questions