0
Maisiedaisie Posted 16 years ago
Grammar

Ellipsis with "and"

Hello,

I have a questions about sentences like a:

a) I'm sitting here and writing this letter.

I feel it has to be:

b) I'm sitting here and I'm writing this letter.

or

c) I'm sitting here writing this letter.

Sentence a sounds incorrect to me. Am I wrong?
Does anybody know the grammatical term for problems like this?

Thanks very much
maisiedaisie
  

Top answer

c) I'm sitting here, (ADD COMMA) writing this letter, when I would much prefer....

  • c) I'm sitting here, (ADD COMMA) writing this letter, when I would much prefer....
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

5 Answers
0
c) I'm sitting here, (ADD COMMA) writing this letter, when I would much prefer....
0
Thanks very much Terryxpress.

Would you say that b is incorrect or that it doesn't make much sense?

maisiedaisie
0
B is correct. It's just overly wordy.
0
(b) is grammatically correct, but no-one would say that: the meaning is still quite clear if we omit words, and so have (c)
0
Thank so much to all of you. You're great!

Emotion: smile

Related Questions