0
Norb Posted 16 years ago
Essay & Composition Writing

Doubt about the use of possesive pronouns

Hello dear friends,

I recently read these paragraphs in a magazine. Although the idea for me is very clear, I am confused about the use of the possesive pronouns like in these examples. I put the original words on red and what I should have done on blue. Thank you very much in advance.




I realized that I’d be hard-pressed to know American Airlines’ purpose. I opened up the magazine in the seat pocket to see if I could find it. There is a letter from the CEO which says something about “all my AA colleagues all over the world who put their hearts and souls into taking you wheresoever you want to go in the world.” At first blush, you might say that is the same thing Southwest says, but it is not quite the same. The AA line is about their (they?) doing something for you, not your (you?) doing something for yourself. It is not liberating: It is creating a dependence.






Let’s switch to medicine and hospitals now. As you all know, at BIDMC, we have a long-standing purpose. It is not a business objective in our strategic plan or mission statement, but it is deeply held: “To treat patients and their families as we would want members of our own family treated. (be treated?).” Achieving this purpose is a full time endeavor for all of us who work here -- including those involved in research and teaching as well as clinical care.

  

Top answer

'Their' and 'your' is the carefully correct choice, because it is not 'you' yourself but 'doing something' that is the topic. 'They' and 'you' are common in informal situations. 'Want (someone) treated' is correct.

  • 'Their' and 'your' is the carefully correct choice, because it is not 'you' yourself but 'doing something' that is the topic.
  • 'They' and 'you' are common in informal situations.
  • 'Want (someone) treated' is correct.
  • In medicine, 'treat' is an active verb: The doctor treats many patients, and he wants them treated in his clinic.
  • '
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
'Their' and 'your' is the carefully correct choice, because it is not 'you' yourself but 'doing something' that is the topic. 'They' and 'you' are common in informal situations.

'Want (someone) treated' is correct. In medicine, 'treat' is an active verb: The doctor treats many patients, and he wants them treated in his clinic. You could use the passive form, but it would have t
0
Thank you very much for your explanation. However I still don't get the Idea on the first concept about their and yours, could you give me another example if possible? and now I have a new doubt about what you just wrote: " In medicine, 'treat' is an active verb: The doctor treats many patients, and he wants them treated in his clinic. You could use the passive form, but it would have
0
[C]ould you give me another example if possible?-- Sure:

I don't like your sitting there; please sit over here.
(cf: I don't like your location; please sit over here.)

It is not you that I dislike; I dislike where you are sitting.

[W]hy don't you say "he wants to treat them in his clinic...-- Because I switched to passive, and
0
thank you so much! I got it! excellent explanations, you're the best.

Best wishes!

Norb.

Related Questions