Done or undone?

Question

1 I went shopping before I had called him. = When I went shopping I hadn't called him.Do you agree that sentence 1 means that the call was NOT made?2 I went shopping before I called him. = When I went shopping I called him.Do you agree that sentence 2 means that the call was made?

AlpheccaStars · Accepted Answer

Ticce1 I went shopping before I ~~had~~ called him.

The past perfect is not good there because there is no reference to an earlier time.

The amended version (simple past) means:

I went shopping. Afterwards I called him.

You did make the call, but it came after your shopping trip.

Another version:

I had called him before I went shopping.

There are two actions. The call came first, followed by the shopping trip.

Another version (Opposite order of actions.). This is somewhat ambiguous because "go shopping" is an action that has a beginning, middle and end. It is not clear if you called after you left the house, while you were in the store, or after to got back home. Most people would assume that your shopping trip had completed.

I had gone shopping before I called him.

CalifJim · Answer

Ticce
1 I went shopping before I had called him. = When I went shopping I hadn't called him. This sounds reasonable.
Do you agree that sentence 1 means that the call was NOT made? This is not implied by the given sentence, so no. We don't know if the call was ever made or not. We only know that the shopping happened before the call IF the call happened at all.

Ticce
2 I went shopping before I called him. = When I went shopping I called him. I wouldn't put it like that. = I went shopping, and then I called him.
Do you agree that sentence 2 means that the call was made? It certainly seems so. Yes.

CJ

Done or undone?

Top answer

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

Related Questions