0
Vincent Teo Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

doing gardening

Can I say,

The grandmother is doing gardening at the garden.

She is gardening in the garden.

She is planting the flower at the garden.

She is cleaning the garden.
  

Top answer

"at the garden" - We use only " in the garden. " She is working in the garden. " - A.

  • "at the garden" - We use only " in the garden.
  • " She is working in the garden.
  • " - A.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

11 Answers
0
"at the garden" - We use only "in the garden. (Meet me at the garden gate.)

"She is gardening in the garden." This is like "typing on the typewriter." She is working in the garden. She is gardening

"She is cleaning weeding / tending the garden."

- A.
0
Thanks. Can I say,

(a)He is cleaning the grass.

(b) He is planting some flowers in the garden.

(c) He is planting (the plants) in the garden.

(d) He is planting in the garden.

P/s: I'm confused. We can say, "in / at / around the park", but we can't say "at the garden", why?
0
Vincent Teo(a)He is cleaning the grass. We don't use this expression with natural turf, but it might be used with the new artificial turf. I'm not sure.

We say, "cutting the grass, mowing / raking the lawn."

(b) He is planting some flowers in the garden. Good.

(c) He is planting (the plants) in the garde
0
Hi Vincent,

In Western English culture, we don't usually call a woman a grandmother, unless she is our grandmother.

We'd typically just say 'a woman' or perhaps 'an elderly woman', although grandmothers these days are often not at all elderly.

Clive
0
Clive we don't usually call a woman a grandmother
Hi Clive. Just being my obstreperous self:

I try to give some leeway because the posts necessarily present things out of context.

Wouldn't it be natural to say, "In my favorite sitcom, the father is always chewing out the son, and the grandmother is always taking the son's side / part." ?
0
Hi,

Hypothetical Situation: If some people were having a show in front of those people who have been marooned in an island for their younger years and have been rescued subsequently. What if they had to showcase some of things they do in their houses, like gardening, fixing the sink, etc. Could they say like this?

OK, we are going to perform gardening for you.
OK, we are goin
0
As a footnote:

Instead of "cleaning the garden", you could say "tidying (up) the garden".

MrP
0
Anonymoussome of things they do in their houses, like gardening, fixing the sink, etc.

OK, we are going to perform gardening our favorite lawns for you.

OK, we are going to perform fixing a faucet for you.
Hi, Anon. The trick here is that (as far as I know) to fix is [only] transitive and to garden is [only] intr
0
MrPedanticInstead of "cleaning the garden", you could say "tidying (up) the garden".
Hi MrP. This rings a bell with me. I think we'd say "cleaning up the garden" in the same way as "tidying up the garden." I think we agree that "tidying the garden" is acceptable while "cleaning the garden" is not. Neither could be substituted for "weeding
0
Yes; I might say that I'd "tidied" the garden if I'd straightened the water ****, picked up a few stray crisp packets, pensively deadheaded the odd hollyhock, etc., all the while hoping that someone else would decide to deal with the impressive sow thistle in the middle of the lawn.

MrP

Related Questions